Vaccine mandates compared to Holocaust in Kansas hearing

    Beard, who is Black, gave the committee a written statement accusing people who won’t work with others who are not vaccinated of “preserving and perpetuating the ideology of a modern-day racist.”

    “We’re basically saying you’re the modern-day Jew,” Beard told the committee in person. “You’re gonna wear that star … and we don’t give a damn if you complain about it or not.”

    Beard, who said he’s vaccinated, referred to the yellow star that the Nazi government in Germany forced Jews to wear before and during World War II. Landwehr thanked him for his comments then later said the remarks made during the committee hearing reminded her of comments in a Holocaust documentary suggesting that the Nazis told Germans, “We’ll take you all down a path.”

    “Now do I believe that that’s what we’re trying to do? I hope not. Because this is America and I don’t want to lose hope in it,” she said.

    No one on the committee objected to the analogy during the committee’s meeting. Democratic Rep. Vic Miller, of Topeka, said afterward that he didn’t “get the reference.”

    Rabbi Moti Rieber, executive director of Kansas Interfaith Action, called the comparison between the Holocaust and vaccine mandates “odious and historically ignorant and offensive.”

    “It’s absurd to even say it,” he said. “Nobody’s going to be put into prison. Nobody’s going to be sent to concentration camps.”

    “This is Holocaust distortion, and it has no place in the legislature,” the statement said.

    The legislative panel — the joint Committee on Government Overreach and the Impact of COVID-19 Mandates — heard a day of testimony, most of it from critics of the mandates. Republican lawmakers already have concluded that Biden’s mandates violate people’s liberties and will damage the economy. Their goal is to find ways for Kansas to resist effectively.

    The committee plans to have another daylong hearing Saturday and to wrap up its work by Thanksgiving.

    During Friday’s hearing, Beard described himself as a conservative Democrat, and he has criticized Democratic Gov. Laura Kelly for not making public statements about the mandates. Her office has said Kansas still has not seen all of the details from the Biden administration.

    Senate President Ty Masterson, a Wichita-area Republican who serves on the committee, said the comparison to the Holocaust shows that for vaccine mandate critics, “They feel like it’s life and death.”

    The Republican president of the West Virginia Senate, a GOP Maine House member and the Oklahoma Republican Party in recent months likened vaccine mandates to Nazi Germany, an infamous Nazi doctor who did experiments on Jews and the persecution of Jewish people by the Nazis.

    Last year, a Kansas county Republican Party chairman who owns a weekly newspaper apologized for a cartoon posted on the paper’s Facebook page that equated an order from Kelly to wear masks in public with the Holocaust.

    After Friday’s committee meeting, Landwehr denied to reporters that she compared vaccine mandates to the Holocaust and again mentioned the documentary.

    “I took offense to, ’We all should follow down a path,” she said. “And having just gone through a documentary over the whole Holocaust, it brought me back to thinking of the Jews being marched to the incinerators.”


    Andy Tsubasa Field is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.


    On Twitter, follow John Hanna at and Andy Tsubasa Field at


    Recent Articles

    Related Stories